Showing posts with label socialism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label socialism. Show all posts

Sunday, June 14, 2009

A Huge Regressive Tax for Americans

We had hoped to report on further FDIC closures, but there were none.

The "Waxman-Markey" bill winding through Congress has an ostensible purpose of capping carbon dioxide emissions. According to US News and World Report, if passed, it will cost the average household as much as $1600 per year, "with low-income households carrying a heavier burden."

A puny, $160 per person tax credit is being proposed to offset the cost, but that will do little to help the average citizen.

Whatever the merits or demerits of a 'carbon tax', it should be presented in a revenue-neutral fashion. The current proposal will have a decided, depressive effect on the economy at a time when such effects are most definitely not needed.

The share of the US economy managed by government is at an all-time high, and still growing fast. This ill-conceived 'energy plan' along with similarly ill-conceived mandatory health insurance programs may push the Nation, already burdened with bailouts and nationalisations, too far down the road of a command economy.

Central planning does not necessarily wreck an economy, of course. Many European nations have a fairly high level of government involvement with the economy and still enjoy a high standard of living. But there, better social welfare results have been and can be expected from the taxes and regulation. We believe that is because socialism, whatever its demerits, is a proactive and coherent movement to distribute public benefits. In the USA, socialism is ideologically extinct, and government intrusion is reactive and self-serving.

A European level of government economic control in the USA will not yield European-style benefits, but an economic catastrophe. Mark our words.

Sunday, April 12, 2009

The Rising Attraction of Socialism

A new Rasmussen Reports telephone poll has found that the percentile of American citizens who favour socialism is 20%, while 53% said capitalism is the better system. This is a very interesting trend, one that we will be watching with great interest. Although 20% is a relative minority in the United States, it is impressive to see this form of Governing garnering such popularity in the U.S.

This deserves a bit of reflection: socialism is antithetical to the American ethos. Socialism is a system which, in a basic interpretation, emphasises the importance of supporting the society as a whole. The Scandinavian countries, Germany, Switzerland, and Canada (as examples) all exhibit successful application of socialist policies; unsurprisingly, these nations give the appearance of being able to more easily soften the harsh blows of the Depression - it remains to be seen how that softening holds up in the future.

As the U.S. is a nation which promotes the individual at the cost of the greater society, socialism is typically regarded as a perversion at best, and a whole-sale attack on "freedom" at worst. For socialism to be supported by 20% of the Citizenry, we can only assume that the 2007 Depression is beginning to make people feel the need for a change.

We can't argue against that need. However, we suspect that people have the idea that President Obama is the man who will bring promised change. As we've said on numerous occasions, we do not think he will deliver the kind of socialism the 20% of Americans are expecting. The United States, since it has been so adamantly opposed to socialism (to the point of its being an outright violation of the Constitution), has no particular framework upon which to build a functional socialist system.

President Obama was elected on the promise of change, and that change is commonly considered to smack of socialism. However, if the continual, hapless bailout-ing of super-huge, super-insolvent banks, and trashy, useless, bankrupt automobile manufacturers is any indication, the Obama Administration's peculiar brand of socialism is the kind previously discovered in the Soviet Union.

It should be said, though, that the Government is merely building upon what previous Administrations have put in place. This is true going back further into American history than most would care to admit. One can point, and rightly so, an accusing finger at President Herbert Hoover as the first major lemon socialist. Lemon socialism is not proper socialism; it is sovietism.

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Pick Yourself Up, Dust Yourself Off - yeah, yeah

It is becoming quite clear to the less ignorant elements that some major restructuring of the economic sphere is in order. A host of economists without egg on their faces (Roubini and Taleb, among others) are calling for wholesale nationalisation of the banking industry. While we don't agree with them, we find the scale of that particular solution appropriate, and preferable to attempts to return to 'business as usual.'

Aside from our preferred solution of returning to bona fide money, any solution which at a minimum gets the world's circulating money out of the hands of the people who squandered so much of it is a step in the right direction. Stricter limits on what the banks may invest the circulating money in would also be an improvement.

Moving on from the financial troubles, it is obvious that neither the faux free-market system of the English-speaking world, nor the faux socialism of the EU can reliably deliver a modicum of prosperity to the masses. Major reform is in order.

One example of the sort of appropriately-scaled reform that ought to be on the table would be a negative income tax as the only form of national income support replacing social security, food stamps, and housing assistance (among other things). The idea has been lurking for quite a while, and supported by both liberals and conservatives, but has never been implemented. In our opinion the reason is that too many people make their living as welfare system bureaucrats.

This leads to the question, is major reform even possible? Has the political system become as dysfunctional as the grotesque that is the economic system? As the Depression grinds along, the presence or absence of political leadership will separate the societies that recover from the ones that don't.

Tuesday, December 9, 2008

Enabling Destructive Economic Behaviour

Although we ourselves are not of the socialist persuasion, we agree with socialists that there are cases where government can actually provide useful services, and at a reasonable cost. So reasonable in fact, that the case for privatisation is not particularly compelling.

Unfortunately, at the national level, the USA seems incapable of delivering that sort of socialism (with the possible exception of the Post Office). Instead it engages in malignant lemon-socialism, where destructive enterprises are rewarded with life-prolonging capital infusions, or outright government ownership.

Take, for example, a number of large banks, Fannie, Freddie, and Wall Street firms. These outfits swindled the world's investors. All issues of criminal fraud aside, their activities were and continue to be enormously destructive economically.

Investors lost confidence in them. Any sane governing authority would simply shut them down. In any sort of free market economy, they would be done already. There are thousands of better run competitors out there to take up the slack. But yet, the Federal Government saw fit to step in and keep them going. Not because no one else was providing some useful service they are. In fact, they aren't producing any useful service at all. Quite the contrary.

Another example is the bailout of the 'Big Three' automobile manufacturers. As stated in a previous post, there are many good, sound business reasons for these companies to go out of business. It's not like there aren't lots of other companies which can make cars. If the USA has a glut of car making capacity, then a fair chunk of it needs to go away.

The core economic problem of the failed Soviet Union was that its central planners took valuable natural resources and turned them into useless waste. Ignoring issues of quality and desirability, they measured output strictly in tonnage. This was socialism at its worst.

Unfortunately, the USA is following in the footsteps of the Soviet Union. Its central planners are diverting ever larger portions of the nation's income into operations that produce little or no benefit. The litany is extensive, but includes bloated 'Defense' and 'Homeland Security', subsidies for airlines, automakers, banks, construction, insurance, mortgage companies, prisons, and real estate brokers.

Spending by Governments at all levels in the USA is about 40% of total national income. Also, about 50% of the population is dependent primarily on government for its income. This is a country fairly deep into some kind of socialism. Is it getting a good value for its commitment? Does the USA have enviable public education? a low rate of incarceration? free health care for all? a first-rate passenger rail system? The answer to these questions is a resounding "No!"

On top of that, Government in the USA is quite involved with the private sector. Does the USA have a healthy industrial base? a healthy balance of payments with the rest of the world? energy security? well-paid, content workers? No, again.

We are profiling a country at the verge of leaving the club of wealthy, advanced nations, if not heading for outright collapse. The response of the political leadership to the 2007 Depression is very telling: bailouts, handouts, and more pork. This will do nothing to make the nation more productive and increase its citizens' income. On the contrary, it will make the nation less productive and exacerbate the decline in income.