Saturday, November 29, 2008

How Likely is Hyperinflation in the USA?

Hyperinflation is certain in Zimbabwe, but can such a thing happen in the USA? Typically, hyperinflation occurs quickly when economies are under extreme stress such as during wartime. The USA had that experience during its Revolution, and many European countries did so during and after the World Wars, and after the collapse of the Soviet Union and its satellites.

Are present economic conditions suitable for the formation of hyperinflation in the USA? The use of paper money creates chronic inflation, but what speeds up inflation to the point where doublings of prices occur not over decades, but weeks?

Typically two factors occur to induce hyperinflation. The first is when governments spend money well beyond their ability to collect taxes. This can occur when spending increases significantly (such as for a war). The second is when tax receipts fall significantly such as during a depression, and the government is unable to borrow money, and yet the government maintains, or even increases, spending.

Clearly, the first factor may come into play since the USA is presently engaged in expensive military campaigns abroad, and is undertaking a nationalisiation of the financial system. More subtly, the federal government has liabilities of over $60,000,000,000,000 (or $200,000 per person) - and growing. There is no way to tax the population sufficiently to honor this commitment in full, so 'printing up' money will be a temptation. Whether debasing the currency will continue at a fairly moderate pace, or will get out-of-control, waits to be seen.

The second factor has come in to play only so far as tax receipts are falling and spending is increasing. The USA still maintains its ability to borrow, at least for a time. Three things may come to pass that may end that privilege. First is the unwillingness of lenders - though at present that seems unlikely since Treasury Debt and Federal Reserve Notes are highly regarded. The second is the incapacity of lenders. As foreign trade crashes, foreign central banks and other corporations will simply have less money to invest in the USA. Increasingly poor domestic investors will be similarly unable to buy. Finally, the knowledge that increasing public borrowing at the expense of private investment (e.g. more money for unemployment benefits and less money to dig new oil wells) would likely make the Depression worse, may prompt the government to 'print' rather than borrow.

We do not care to make specific predictions of how much prices will rise and how quickly. We do believe that hyperinflation in the USA is a definite risk, as the 2008 Depression causes increasing income loss. At the moment, hyperinflation is not imminent, but stand by for further updates.

2 comments:

Thai said...

Nice post. I clicked on your icon from Sudden Debt (where I tend to hang) when I noticed you blog name-- I also tend to think of myself as a 'frugal scotsman".

You did forget to mention one last possibility: simple US default without resorting to printing. Under this scenario we would see the granddaddy of all deflations and you would really want to keep cash under your mattress.

So the bet as to how this all plays out still stands on how all the players in our slow motion 3 dimensional societal tragedy of the commons behave... Or as Yogi Berra once said "Its tough to make predictions, especially about the future"

PS-I noticed your other blogs are subscriber only. How does one get a feed to your other reports? I am not an investor but I am an interested observer of life.

Regards

Adam Smith said...

A simple US default would indeed be an interesting scenario, and a complete volte-face of foreign and economic policy of the last 120 years or so. Simple default would effectively cut off imports (except probably from Iraq), and trash globalism. I shudder to think that the country's leaders could be so clueless as to destroy the USA's preeminence in the world politically and economically, but I wouldn't bet against it either...The other blogs are not yet operational. We hope to ramp them up at a rate of about one per month.