FDIC Bank Failure Report - Impossibly Late Edition

Apologies to all, but it's been a busy week. We're wrapping up our summer efforts, and save a few last projects we will soon have more time to devote to this blog.

***

This week, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation closed seven banks: Partners Bank, of Naples, FL; American United Bank, of Lawrenceville, GA; Hillcrest Bank Florida, of Naples, FL; Flagship National Bank, of Bradenton, FL; Bank of Elmwood, of Racine, WI; Riverview Community Bank, of Otsego, MN; and First Dupage Bank, of Westmont, IL. The total assets of the closed banks were $1,163,900,000, and total deposits were approximately $1,032,100,000. The cost to the FDIC is estimated at $356,700,000.

According to our methodology, the recoverable value of the bank was $675,400,000, or only 58.03% of the declared asset value. This makes this week's closure slightly above the cumulative recoverability since December, which stands at 57.46% (essentially unchanged from last week's 57.45%).

Cumulative cost-to-FDIC was brought to $46,457,800,000. This closure brings the total declared assets of FDIC-failed banks (since December of 2007) to $480,962,480,000, and total FDIC-insured deposits to $322,801,020,000. The recoverable value of all failed banks was only $276,343,220,000 (57.46% of the declared value).

***

First off, we welcome Wisconsin to the 2007 Depression; the Land of Cheese has enjoyed the scent of its first - of many - bank failures. Additionally, we pat ourselves on the back, because at long last Florida is receiving the attention we predicted it would (see the commentary at the end of our piece). We called it almost a month ago, so please pardon us while we feel terribly smart. At any rate, Florida is in for a very, very painful time, have no doubt; the whole State's banking system is a morass of ultimate financial doom. We don't know if this is the beginning of that pain, or just a blip, but we're quite confident that Florida is going to see vast numbers of banks falling dead in their tracks from toxic mortgages, et cetera.

We noticed a surprising trend with this week's closures: a large percentage (95.27%) of the assets of all closed banks were successfully sold off, either outright or under a loss-share agreement between the FDIC and the acquiring institution. We don't have much back data (we'll work on that), so this might be a fluke of the week... but we wonder if the Federal Government's calling the recession over is actually working. Call us crazy, but we're just not feeling the love on this one. If the 'great recession' were actually over, we would expect to see that in improving quality of bank's assets. They have definitely not improved.

However, is seems that acquiring institutions feel the economy will be improving in the future, so they're happy to snap up most of the assets of the failed banks, no matter how toxic. The frisky animal spirits have possessed them at last, so they put on their war paint, do a victory dance, and march off to position themselves for the 'great recovery.' Apparently these acquiring institutions have forgotten they are akin to wolves; wolves can only consume fresh meat, and it seems these predators haven't noticed their prey is rotten. We don't know when the nasty effects of bad assets will start to bother the predator banks, but when the effects start it will be exciting. If acquiring institutions start to be closed by the FDIC, expect the U.S. to take the mother of all nosedives.

***

On the basis of the ratio of bank closures to population (i.e. simply the number of failures in the State, with no account of assets or deposits), the ten most afflicted States are listed here. Only those States which have two or more closures are considered.

1. Georgia
2. Nevada
3. Illinois
4. Minnesota (up from #6)
5. Utah (down from #4)
6. Kansas (down from #5)
7. Oregon
8. Missouri
9. Colorado
10. Florida (new to list)

The recoverable value represents how much of declared assets are actually worth on the open market. The following are the ten States with the lowest recoverable value; only those States which have had two or more closures are considered in this analysis.

1. Florida (32.44%)
2. California (40.11%)
3. Colorado (42.76%)
4. Michigan (43.07%)
5. Nevada (50.13%)
6. Georgia (53.74%, down from 53.76%)
7. Utah (55.39%)
8. Arizona (56.08%)
9. Washington (56.18%)
10. North Carolina (56.7%)

***

Well, shucks, more back-patting for us: Florida is now officially on both lists. We fully expect the State to ratchet up to the #1 spot on closures-to-population, and stay firmly in the lead on the recoverable value scale. The collapse of Florida's finances will likely be coupled with the final catastrophic implosion of the vast majority of well-off senior citizens' own finances. Why? We suspect that most of the elderly retirees in Florida have a big portion of their wealth in over-valued real estate, and when the State's real estate bubble pops and that value goes down, down, down, those seniors are not going to have much to fall back on. Social Security will not be enough to support them in the style to which they've become accustomed, and they will be forced out of their homes and into the homes of their children.

That's, of course, making the rash assumption that their children still have homes of their own. If the Baby Boomers have taken the hit at around the same time, the United States is going to see a large indigent population of elderly and Baby Boomers, whinging about how it isn't fair. No one in power will be listening, we suspect; the ear of the Federal Government is firmly owned by banks. Indeed, at that point the Government might not have any money at all to throw around - at least, no money that can actually buy anything.

The question rattling around in our mind is this: is Florida the first domino in a really big economic catastrophe? Or will it be another California, and simply be a bigger sag in the overarching, slow-motion collapse of the U.S. economy? We really don't know, but we could certainly see it either way. We'll be pondering that thought for a later blog post.