The True Victim of the Depression

We read an article from the International Herald Tribune which we found laughably uninsightful. Mr. Stephen Schwarzman, CEO of Blackstone Group, remarks that the world has lost about 40% to 45% of its wealth. Our cynical side wonders if he is covertly commenting on his personal portfolio, but we assume he is being honest in his estimation of the drop of the world's 'wealth.'

Even if Mr. Schwarzman's number is accepted as reasonably accurate -- which we do -- his comment is purely nonsensical: the 'wealth' he refers to was never real. It was perceptual wealth; it existed only because at least two people at the peak of valuation said it did: the credulous buyer, and the less-credulous seller. This fast-evaporating 'wealth' was patently illusory, as it had all the substance and reality of a mirage.

Beyond this basic falsehood of Mr. Schwarzman's comment lies the big, black truth that no one likes to think about. Depressions are not necessarily about destroying wealth; rather, they destroy excess. Excess demand, excess consumption, excess space, excess production, excess capacity, excess valuation, excess credit. These are the things upon which a depression feasts; nothing so trite and pedestrian as perceptual wealth. The most destructive feat of a depression, though, is how effectively it can eliminate productive capacity of an economy.

Within this destruction, though, is a major problem. All depressions of the past have occurred when energy was not a limiting factor. The populace did not wonder where the energy to renew the economy was going to come from. It was tacitly assumed, and rightly so, the energy necessary to rebuild economic activity was abundant.

We opine such a comfortable assurance is not present in the 2007 Depression. Demand destruction in world-wide oil consumption is a given, and some have mentioned that it is an end to the Peak Oil debate. We beg to differ: this destruction has guaranteed Peak Oil is upon the world (whether from the limits of Nature or the limits of Humanity is immaterial). The oil industry -- from whence the lifeblood of industrial civilisation flows -- is in danger of irreparable harm, as Simmons & Company International reports.

With the severe downturn in oil use, many oil wells, rigs and refineries are being spooled down... permanently. Most of this equipment is utterly antique, and can never be restarted at any cost; it is too rusty and too run-down, and needs to be replaced. On top of that, vast swaths of the industry's ageing workforce are retiring, and there are not enough new workers adequately trained to replace this loss of hard-earned talent.

At some point in the not-too-near future, the hard and unyielding ceiling of oil production capacity will become painfully apparent. By Simmons & Co.'s estimation, it will take upwards of $100 trillion to rebuild the world's energy production facilities, and make them a viable entity for the future. We have the suspicion that the money, the interest, and the labour will never be found. Too many people seem to believe that the oil industry is a profit-squeezing monster - instead of the abused and starving industry in danger of utter collapse it is.