Expanding Government, Declining Economy

USA Today reports "Benefit Spending Soars to a New High". 'Benefits' being the euphemism for 'Welfare', now that there is no shame in being on the dole. In any case, state and federal welfare payments are now one-sixth of Americans' income.

As the Depression grinds on, there will be considerable pressure from all sides to maintain and expand 'benefits'. These 'benefits' will have to come out of taxpayer pockets, one way or another. Since visible taxes will probably not be raised enough to cover the swollen 'benefit' roles, there will be some of that hidden tax coming down the pike - inflation.

Redistributing income, up to a point, may have some merits. But if the productive elements of society - most of whom are having a fairly rough time of it lately, too - are overburdened with increasing taxes, there will be further decline in economic activity.

As we have discussed repeatedly before, there is a range of government spending in an economy which is optimal, and spending below or above that range is destructive. At present, government spending at all levels (according to the helpful folks at usgovernmentspending.com) is a 45.2% share of the economy as a whole. This is up from a 37% share in the last fiscal year.

The rate of increase in the share is a whopping 22%! If the share were to increase at that rate for just another two years, the USA would end up two thirds of its economy (mis)managed by the State - a comparable level to Eastern Europe in the Soviet era. And probably with similar results.

Of course, the Nation's leaders are emphatically stating that since recovery is around the corner, there will be no need for further increases. We beg to disagree on the recovery part. Recovery is not around the corner. Whatever spin may be being put on 'the numbers' - they are in fact truly terrible.

In the face of Great Depression II, Mr. Obama's administration will not be able to resist expanding 'benefits', as well as bailing out and nationalising banks, insurance companies, car makers, airlines, airplane makers, and God-only-knows who else.

We believe, with some confidence, the deeper Uncle Sam dives into the economy, the worse the economy will perform. Since the leadership seems infected with some sort of intervention mania, we also anticipate that the lack of recovery will promote ever-larger bailout and 'recovery' schemes. These in turn will hurt the economy even more. We can't anticipate how long these destructive cycles will continue, but probably long enough to turn the USA into a dramatically poorer nation.