Thursday, December 11, 2008

"Say it ain't so, champ!"

A friend tells us this line comes from The Champ (1931), when the young Jackie Cooper finds that his hero isn't as heroic and upstanding as one would have hoped. So, too, are the best and brightest of Wall Street losing their stature. Today, for example, saw the discovery of what is probably the second biggest Ponzi scheme in financial history (bested only by the original, Charles Ponzi).

The mastermind? Bernard Madoff, former chairman of the NASDAQ. The grand total? Clocking in at around $50 billion or so. This tops the other Ponzi scheme recently ended, a measly $3.5 billion swindle orchestrated by Tom Petters, a Minnesota 'entrepreneur'-cum-felon. Both these men ran schemes which ripped off the gullible for fun and profit; both these men are criminals. Both these men were respected investors; the news of their unscrupulousness is "inconceivable" to their cohorts.

Hahahaha. As Bugs Bunny says, "aw, go on."

These two swindles are telling, however, for a trend of the 2007 Depression. A Ponzi scheme -- indeed, any confidence scam -- is inherently unstable, even in the best of times. The 2007 Depression is going to squeeze these sorts of swindles into non-functionality, and some may blow up spectacularly. There are, however, more swindles out there than just the average Ponzi scheme, and many of them come in forms one wouldn't necessarily expect.

Take banking: one puts one's money in an account, and then pretends it's still in the bank. Unfortunately, one's money does not simply sit in the bank's vault; it goes into, say... synthetic CDOs; or stock of Fannie Mae and Freddic Mac; or sub-prime loans. The point is, one's money is not in the bank anymore. In fact, we'd argue it probably isn't anywhere anymore. Yes, if one wanted to take out one's money, one can simply walk into a bank and withdraw it. But what if every depositor of the bank wanted their money? The bank never holds enough physical cash to cover its deposits; it can't afford to. The bank, like Mr. Madoff's and Mr. Petters' Ponzi schemes, would implode, and depositors would be left holding the bag, hoping that government insurance pays out.

But the biggest swindle, in our opinion, is money itself. We use it every day: these green pieces of paper get us our food, heat, and shiny, shiny gold. They're legal tender, all right -- every bill tells us so -- but who guarantees this? The Federal Reserve, we presume, since they're the ones who own them... but the Fed is just a bank. We ask: what happens when everyone metaphorically cashes in their dollar bills to hold something tangible? "Say it ain't so, champ!" will be the general cry.

No comments: